If you’re looking for an H&R Block alternative, the cheapest option isn’t automatically the best one. The right choice depends on the complexity of your return, the support you want, how quickly you need answers, and whether you need an accountant for more than one tax return.
I’m Puneet Singh, Founder and Principal of Nanak Accountants & Associates. I’ve spent more than 12 years working with individuals, investors and businesses on accounting and tax matters.
I see people make the same comparison mistake often: they compare the first price they see instead of comparing the service behind that price. A straightforward salary return and a return involving a rental property, capital gains or a business are not the same job.
So I have looked at the main H&R Block alternatives through a practical lens: what each provider is designed to do, how the service is delivered, how transparent the pricing appears, what level of human support is offered, and where each option makes the most sense.
TL;DR
For a simple DIY return, ATO myTax is the obvious low-cost option. For online tax-agent support, GoTax, Etax and TaxReturn.com.au are worth comparing. If you prefer a physical tax-office network, ITP is a natural alternative. If your return involves business income, property, CGT or broader tax planning, Nanak Accountants is the type of full-service accounting relationship I would consider.
- Best free DIY option: ATO myTax
- Best low-cost online tax-agent option: GoTax
- Best established online tax-agent option: Etax
- Best for clear package pricing: TaxReturn.com.au
- Best traditional tax-office alternative: ITP
- Best for taxpayers considering a refund-advance model: Tax Today
- Best for more complex individual tax matters: MHA Accounting
- Best for tax, accounting and ongoing planning: Nanak Accountants
- Best for fixed-fee online accountant access: Nebula Accounting
- Best for migrants and international tax situations: TaxBank
H&R Block’s current Australian assisted services start from $109 for its basic package, with higher packages for standard, rental and business situations. It also offers DIY online tax returns and operates more than 400 offices across Australia. H&R Block pricing Because the providers below offer different service models, I would compare like with like rather than choose on the headline price alone.
“There is no single best H&R Block alternative. A simple return may suit DIY myTax, while a more complex return may justify an online tax agent or a full accounting relationship.”
Factors I Judge the H&R Block Alternatives On
I do not judge a tax-return provider on price alone. When I recommend a provider to someone, I want to understand what the customer is actually buying and what happens when something needs attention.
Price and total cost
I look at the quoted fee, what is included, what attracts an additional charge, and whether the advertised starting price is realistic for the customer’s situation.
Pricing transparency
A provider should make it reasonably clear what the customer is paying for. If the fee can change, I want to know what triggers that change.
Response time and access
I look for practical access to help and clear communication channels. If a customer has a question, who answers it and how can they reach that person?
Customer feedback
I look at the volume and recency of public reviews and, more importantly, recurring themes around communication, clarity, fees and service. A tiny review sample should not be treated as representative.
Tax complexity
I check whether the provider’s published service range covers rental property, shares, CGT, crypto, sole-trader income, foreign income and business matters where relevant.
Human involvement
I want to know whether a registered tax agent or accountant reviews the return or whether the customer is mainly using software.
After-lodgement support
I consider what happens if the ATO asks for more information or the client needs help understanding the assessment.
Convenience
Online lodgement, phone support, appointments, document upload and physical offices can all matter, depending on the customer.
Overall value
My final judgement is always a balance of fee, expertise, access, transparency and peace of mind.
The right comparison is not simply fee versus fee. I judge the complete client experience: price, clarity, response, expertise, convenience and support after lodgement.
1. ATO myTax – Best Free H&R Block Alternative
If your tax affairs are straightforward and you are comfortable preparing your own return, myTax is the first option I would compare. It is the ATO’s online tax-lodgement pathway for individuals through myGov.
The attraction is obvious: you avoid paying a private tax-preparation fee and you control the lodgement yourself.
Best suited to
- Employees with straightforward income
- People with ordinary deductions
- Taxpayers confident using online services
- People whose return does not need specialist tax advice
Where it wins
Cost and control. You are not paying someone else to prepare the return.
Where it falls short
The responsibility stays with you. You need to understand what to report, what you can claim and how the rules apply to your circumstances. I would be more cautious if the return involves a rental property, CGT, business income, foreign income or other judgement-heavy areas.
Verdict
Excellent for a genuinely simple return. It is not a replacement for professional advice when the tax position is complex.
Read the detailed review: 1. ATO myTax
Public information checked: August 2026 – https://www.ato.gov.au/individuals-and-families/income-and-deductions/income-tax-returns
“Excellent for a genuinely simple return. It is not a replacement for professional advice when the tax position is complex. This is an editorial fit judgement based on the provider’s published service model, not a claim that it is universally better than H&R Block.”
2. GoTax – Best Low-Cost Online Tax-Agent Alternative
GoTax is aimed at people who want online tax-agent support without moving into a traditional accounting-firm model. Its current pricing page lists 2026 individual tax returns from $115, with separate starting prices for rentals, capital gains, contractors and small business.
Best suited to
- Employees
- Contractors and sole traders
- People with rental property or CGT
- Taxpayers who want a registered tax agent but prefer an online process
Where it wins
Published pricing is relatively easy to understand, and the service range extends beyond simple salary returns.
Where it falls short
A standard return and a rental or CGT return are priced differently, so I would get the fee for your actual circumstances rather than rely on the entry price.
Verdict
A sensible shortlist option when price matters but you still want tax-agent involvement.
Read the detailed review: 2. GoTax
Public information checked: August 2026 – https://www.gotax.au/pricing/
“A sensible shortlist option when price matters but you still want tax-agent involvement. This is an editorial fit judgement based on the provider’s published service model, not a claim that it is universally better than H&R Block.”
3. Etax – Best Established Online Tax-Agent Option
Etax is designed around an online tax-agent model. It allows customers to prepare their return digitally while receiving accountant support and review.
Best suited to
- Online-first taxpayers
- Employees
- Investors
- People who prefer digital communication
- Taxpayers who want accountant involvement
Where it wins
Convenience. You can handle the process online without needing to organise a traditional office appointment. Etax also publishes fees from $87.49 and itemised pricing for several common extras.
Where it falls short
I would not compare only the entry fee. Rental schedules, CGT and other items can affect the final cost, so the relevant question is what your specific return will cost.
Verdict
One of the more obvious H&R Block alternatives for someone who wants professional tax help through an online workflow.
Read the detailed review: 3. Etax
Public information checked: August 2026 – https://www.etax.com.au/etax-fees/
“One of the more obvious H&R Block alternatives for someone who wants professional tax help through an online workflow. This is an editorial fit judgement based on the provider’s published service model, not a claim that it is universally better than H&R Block.”
4. TaxReturn.com.au – Best for Clear Package Pricing
TaxReturn.com.au is particularly useful for people who want to see defined packages before starting. Its published pricing currently lists $79 for Standard, $179 for Complex and $199 for Rental or Business.
Best suited to
- Employees
- People with investments
- Rental-property owners
- Taxpayers wanting an online process
Where it wins
The package structure makes it easier to see the difference between standard, complex and rental or business work.
Where it falls short
The package can change when additional information or schedules are needed. I would therefore confirm the final package for your circumstances before signing.
Verdict
A strong comparison point for price-conscious taxpayers who value a clearly published package structure.
Read the detailed review: 4. TaxReturn.com.au
Public information checked: August 2026 – https://www.taxreturn.com.au/pricing/
“A strong comparison point for price-conscious taxpayers who value a clearly published package structure. This is an editorial fit judgement based on the provider’s published service model, not a claim that it is universally better than H&R Block.”
5. ITP – Best for a Traditional Tax-Office Alternative
ITP is a more traditional tax-agent alternative. It offers online returns, phone and email support, and a network of offices, so customers can choose between remote and face-to-face service.
Best suited to
- People who prefer an office
- Taxpayers who want online or phone options
- People with more than one income source
- Customers who want an established tax-agent network
Where it wins
Choice of service channel. ITP’s online process covers common areas such as salary, rental income, shares, business income and foreign income, while its office network gives customers a face-to-face option.
Where it falls short
If I were choosing an office-based service, I would check the specific branch and the person handling the return. A national network does not mean every customer has the same experience.
Verdict
A natural H&R Block alternative for people who still want the option of a physical tax office.
Read the detailed review: 5. ITP
Public information checked: August 2026 – https://itp.com.au/online-tax-return/
“A natural H&R Block alternative for people who still want the option of a physical tax office. This is an editorial fit judgement based on the provider’s published service model, not a claim that it is universally better than H&R Block.”
6. Tax Today – Best for People Considering a Refund-Advance Model
Tax Today is worth looking at for a different reason: it offers a refund-advance model alongside tax-return services. The key point is to distinguish the tax refund from the separate financial arrangement used to access expected refund money sooner.
Best suited to
- People focused on cash-flow timing
- Taxpayers wanting online, phone or office options
- People who want to compare refund-advance services
Where it wins
It addresses a specific need: access to expected refund money before the normal ATO payment cycle is complete.
Where it falls short
An advance is not the same thing as an ATO refund. There are separate terms and costs, so I would compare the total financial cost before choosing this route.
Verdict
Interesting for speed-focused taxpayers, but I would judge it on the economics of the complete arrangement, not the speed headline.
Read the detailed review: 6. Tax Today
Public information checked: August 2026 – https://taxtoday.com.au/information/faqs/
“Interesting for speed-focused taxpayers, but I would judge it on the economics of the complete arrangement, not the speed headline. This is an editorial fit judgement based on the provider’s published service model, not a claim that it is universally better than H&R Block.”
7. MHA Accounting – Best for More Complex Individual Tax Returns
MHA Accounting is the kind of alternative I would consider once a tax return includes property, capital gains, ABN income or other complexity. Its individual-tax offering covers employees, sole traders, property investors and small businesses.
Best suited to
- Property investors
- Sole traders
- People with CGT
- Taxpayers whose return has outgrown a simple tax-filing model
Where it wins
Scope. Its published individual-tax services cover a broader set of circumstances than a basic salary-only return.
Where it falls short
For a complex return, I would ask who is preparing and reviewing it, what is included in the fee, how communication works and what happens after lodgement.
Verdict
More relevant when the tax return has become a technical problem rather than a simple filing task.
Read the detailed review: 7. MHA Accounting
Public information checked: August 2026 – https://mhaaccounting.com.au/individual-tax-returns/
“More relevant when the tax return has become a technical problem rather than a simple filing task. This is an editorial fit judgement based on the provider’s published service model, not a claim that it is universally better than H&R Block.”
8. Nanak Accountants – Best for Tax, Accounting and Ongoing Planning
If your tax return is connected to a bigger financial decision, I believe the accountant should understand the bigger picture.
I’m Puneet Singh, Founder and Principal of Nanak Accountants & Associates, and after 12+ years in accounting, I do not see the tax return as an isolated form. Clients often start with a tax question and then need help with business structure, investment property, tax planning, bookkeeping or next-year decisions.
Best suited to
- Business owners
- Sole traders
- Property investors
- Individuals needing tax planning
- Clients who want tax and accounting under one relationship
Where it wins
Nanak combines tax returns with broader accounting, tax-planning and tax-minimisation services. The firm’s current site lists individual tax filing from $120 and separate business tax-return and advisory services.
Where it falls short
If you have a very simple return and only care about the lowest filing fee, a DIY or online tax service may cost less. I would not recommend a full-service accounting relationship just to submit a simple return.
Verdict
For people who want tax preparation alongside accounting and forward planning, this is the model I believe deserves serious consideration.
Read the detailed review: 8. Nanak Accountants
Public information checked: August 2026 – https://nanakaccountants.com.au/
“For people who want tax preparation alongside accounting and forward planning, this is the model I believe deserves serious consideration. This is an editorial fit judgement based on the provider’s published service model, not a claim that it is universally better than H&R Block.”
9. Nebula Accounting – Best for Fixed-Fee Online Accountant Access
Nebula positions itself as a fully online, Australia-wide accounting firm with fixed-fee tax returns and direct access to accountants. It currently publishes individual packages from $140 for simple returns, $190 for standard returns, $300 for investor returns and $390+ for complex returns, excluding GST.
Best suited to
- People who prefer online accounting
- Investors
- Sole traders
- Business owners
- Clients who value fixed-fee pricing
Where it wins
The pricing model is explicit, and the firm says customers deal directly with an accountant rather than a generic support channel.
Where it falls short
Fixed-fee does not mean every return costs the same. I would still confirm exactly what your package includes and whether anything falls outside it.
Verdict
A useful alternative when fixed pricing and direct accountant access are important to you.
Read the detailed review: 9. Nebula Accounting
Public information checked: August 2026 – https://nebulaaccounting.au/tax-returns.html
“A useful alternative when fixed pricing and direct accountant access are important to you. This is an editorial fit judgement based on the provider’s published service model, not a claim that it is universally better than H&R Block.”
10. TaxBank – Best for Migrants and International Tax Situations
TaxBank is a specialist alternative rather than a general recommendation for every taxpayer. It focuses on migrants, visa holders and international workers, with services that cover residency, foreign income and related Australian tax issues.
Best suited to
- New Australian residents
- Migrants
- Temporary residents
- People with foreign income
- People leaving Australia
Where it wins
Specialisation. Residency and foreign-income questions can create issues that do not appear in a standard resident salary return.
Where it falls short
If your tax affairs are ordinary and entirely Australian, specialist migrant-tax services may add little value.
Verdict
A sensible specialist option when migration or international income is central to your tax position.
Read the detailed review: 10. TaxBank
Public information checked: August 2026 – https://www.taxbank.com.au/for/migrants-new-residents
“A sensible specialist option when migration or international income is central to your tax position. This is an editorial fit judgement based on the provider’s published service model, not a claim that it is universally better than H&R Block.”
Which H&R Block Alternative Is Right for You?
I would make the choice from the tax problem backwards. Start with what you need to report, how much help you want, and whether you want a relationship beyond this year’s return.
Simple salary return
Compare myTax first. If you want an accountant to review it, compare GoTax, Etax or TaxReturn.com.au.
Rental property
Prioritise experience with rental deductions, depreciation and CGT. Compare the full fee, not a basic-return price.
Shares or crypto
Ask whether CGT schedules and transaction-heavy situations are included in the quoted fee.
Sole trader or contractor
Choose a provider that understands both your business income and the individual tax return.
Business owner
A broader accounting firm may add more value because tax, bookkeeping, BAS and planning can interact.
Migrant or temporary resident
Check that the provider understands tax residency and foreign-income rules.
Need face-to-face service
ITP and H&R Block are natural network-style comparisons. Check the specific office and adviser.
Want ongoing tax planning
Compare full-service accounting firms such as Nanak rather than focusing only on annual lodgement fees.
“Choose the provider that matches the complexity of your tax affairs. A cheap filing service can be good value for a simple return, while a complex return may justify paying for broader professional support.”
How to Choose an H&R Block Alternative Without Overpaying
Decide whether you need DIY or professional help.
If you know the rules and your return is simple, DIY may be enough. If you are unsure about deductions, CGT, property or business income, professional review can be worthwhile.
List every income source.
Include salary, interest, dividends, rent, business or ABN income, shares, crypto and foreign income where relevant.
List the complicated parts.
Write down rental property, CGT, business income, overseas income, multiple employers, trusts or other issues.
Ask for the fee for your actual return.
Do not compare a basic advertised package with the price of a complex return.
Ask who prepares and reviews the return.
You should know whether an actual tax professional reviews the work.
Ask how quickly questions are answered.
Response time matters when you need to clarify a claim or respond to the ATO.
Ask what happens after lodgement.
Find out who handles an ATO query, amendment or follow-up.
Check registration.
Use the Tax Practitioners Board register to verify a tax practitioner where appropriate.
“The safest way to compare providers is to compare the same scope of work, the same level of professional involvement and the same level of after-lodgement support.”
When a Full-Service Accountant Makes More Sense
A basic tax-return service is built around one task: preparing and lodging the return. That can be exactly what you need. But once the return is connected to business decisions or investments, the useful conversation changes.
I often find that the tax return exposes a wider question: should the business structure change, is an investment strategy still suitable, are tax payments being planned properly, or should records be improved before next year?
That is where a full-service accounting relationship can become more valuable than a one-off filing service. Nanak offers individual and business tax returns, business accounting, tax planning and tax-minimisation services for clients who need that broader support.
“A full-service accountant is most useful when your tax return is part of a larger financial picture and you want advice that continues after lodgement.”
Frequently Asked Questions About H&R Block Alternatives
What is the best alternative to H&R Block in Australia?
There isn’t one universal winner.
For simple DIY returns, myTax is the strongest low-cost option. For online tax-agent help, GoTax, Etax and TaxReturn.com.au are worth comparing. For broader tax and accounting support, I would include Nanak in the shortlist.
Is there a cheaper alternative to H&R Block?
Yes.
myTax can be used for eligible self-lodged returns without a private tax-agent fee, and several online providers publish lower starting prices than H&R Block’s assisted packages. The important part is comparing the fee for your actual return, not just the headline price.
Is an online tax agent better than H&R Block?
It can be a better fit if you prefer a fully digital process.
Etax, GoTax and TaxReturn.com.au are examples. If you prefer sitting with someone in person, the advantage may shift towards a provider with physical offices.
Is an accountant better than a tax-return service?
It depends on the return.
If your tax affairs are simple, you may not need a broader accounting relationship. If you have a rental property, business, CGT, multiple structures or ongoing planning needs, a full-service accountant can be more useful because the work extends beyond annual lodgement.
How do I choose the right H&R Block alternative?
Start with complexity, then compare total cost, transparency, response time, customer feedback, human review and after-lodgement support.
I would also check that the person providing tax-agent services is properly registered with the Tax Practitioners Board.
Need Help Choosing the Right Tax Accountant?
If you are unsure whether you need a simple tax-return service or a broader accounting relationship, the best place to start is with your circumstances rather than a price list. At Nanak Accountants & Associates, we can review what you are dealing with and tell you what level of support makes sense.
Book a consultation with Nanak Accountants & Associates
Nanak Accountants & Associates – https://nanakaccountants.com.au/
Important Information
H&R Block and Etax are trademarks of their respective owners. Nanak Accountants & Associates is not affiliated with, or endorsed by, either company. Competitor information in this article is drawn from publicly available sources and was checked in August 2026. Fees and services may have changed – check directly with each provider.
Nanak Accountants & Associates is a registered tax agent (26113345). The Tax Practitioners Board maintains a public register of tax agents at tpb.gov.au, which also explains how to make a complaint about a tax practitioner.
Sources Used for Competitor Verification
- H&R Block Australia – pricing and services
- H&R Block Australia – tax return service
- GoTax – pricing
- Etax – fees
- TaxReturn.com.au – pricing
- ITP – online tax return
- Tax Today – FAQs
- MHA Accounting – individual tax returns
- Nanak Accountants & Associates
- Nanak Accountants – business tax returns
- Nebula Accounting – tax returns
- TaxBank – migrants and new residents
- ATO – individual tax returns
- Tax Practitioners Board