Why this comparison matters
Every tax season, someone asks me the same question: “Is eTax the best option, or should I change accountants?”
My answer is usually the same—it depends on what you expect from your accountant.
If all you need is someone to lodge a straightforward tax return, there are plenty of capable firms. But if you’re a property investor, sole trader, contractor, or small business owner, the right accountant can save you considerably more through planning than through simply preparing a return.
Melbourne now has more qualified tax professionals than ever before. According to the Tax Practitioners Board, Victoria has 17,531 registered tax practitioners, and Australia welcomed 4,373 new registered practitioners during 2024–25. That’s creating healthier competition and giving taxpayers better choices across both boutique and national firms.
For this review, I didn’t look at marketing claims. I scored each firm using the same five parameters that I personally believe matter when choosing an accountant.
How I rated each firm

These ratings are my independent professional opinion based on publicly available information, service offerings, client experience, and industry reputation. They are not sponsored rankings.
Read our detailed Clear Tax Accountants Review.
1. H&R Block
Overall Rating: 9.4/10
H&R Block is probably Australia’s most recognised tax preparation brand. What I appreciate most is consistency. Whether someone books online or visits one of their Melbourne offices, the process is well organised and predictable.
I generally recommend H&R Block to employees and families whose tax affairs are relatively straightforward. Their strength isn’t necessarily complex tax structuring—it’s delivering reliable tax returns at scale.
Tax expertise — 9.5/10
H&R Block prepares thousands of Australian individual tax returns every year. Their accountants are particularly strong with PAYG income, work-related deductions, rental property basics, and standard employee claims. The only reason I didn’t score it higher is that highly specialised business advisory isn’t its primary focus.
Client service — 9.2/10
The service is professional and dependable. As with any large national network, the experience can vary slightly depending on which office or accountant you work with, so I deducted a small margin.
Turnaround time — 9.3/10
Their workflow is efficient, especially during tax season. Online appointments and document collection make the process relatively smooth, although July naturally becomes their busiest period.
Pricing transparency — 9.4/10
I like that pricing is generally explained before engagement. Clients have a good understanding of what they’re paying for, particularly for standard individual returns.
Overall value — 9.4/10
For salary and wage earners, H&R Block offers excellent value through accessibility, reliability, and nationwide coverage.
Best suited for: Employees, first-time taxpayers, and straightforward individual tax returns.
2. eTax Australia
Overall Rating: 9.2/10
eTax Australia deserves credit for making tax returns genuinely convenient. The platform has built its reputation around a digital-first experience, and it does that exceptionally well.
For busy professionals who don’t want to visit an office, eTax is one of the better online options available. Where I think it becomes less suitable is when a client’s financial situation grows beyond a standard individual return.
The platform performs very well for individual taxpayers, contractors, and common deduction scenarios. More complex structures involving companies, trusts, or strategic tax planning usually benefit from a more advisory-based approach.
Client service — 9.1/10
Communication is responsive and efficient. The experience is almost entirely digital, which many clients love, although others still prefer having one dedicated accountant they can speak to directly.
Turnaround time — 9.4/10
This is eTax’s strongest area. Digital document uploads and remote servicing reduce delays and make lodging a return remarkably quick.
Pricing transparency — 9.3/10
The pricing structure is easy to understand before lodging, which creates confidence and avoids unexpected surprises.
Overall value — 9.2/10
If convenience is your highest priority, eTax delivers exactly what it promises.
Best suited for: Individuals who prefer completing their entire tax return online.
3. Kelly+Partners
Overall Rating: 9.0/10
Kelly+Partners is quite different from the first two firms. I see them less as a tax preparation business and more as a business advisory practice that also happens to prepare tax returns.
That distinction makes them particularly valuable for company directors and business owners looking beyond annual compliance.
Tax expertise — 9.3/10
The firm has strong capability across company tax, business structures, and strategic financial advice. Their expertise extends well beyond individual tax returns.
Client service — 8.9/10
The service is knowledgeable and consultative. My slightly lower score reflects that the firm is positioned more towards premium advisory rather than quick tax preparation.
Turnaround time — 8.8/10
Business advisory naturally involves more meetings and planning, so work often takes longer than high-volume individual tax firms.
Pricing transparency — 8.7/10
Fees are generally tailored to the scope of work rather than fixed upfront. That’s common for advisory firms, although it makes budgeting slightly less predictable.
Overall value — 9.0/10
For growing businesses, the additional strategic advice can justify the higher engagement model.
Best suited for: Companies, directors, and growing businesses.
4. Wilson Pateras
Overall Rating: 8.8/10
Wilson Pateras is one of those firms that has built its reputation through long-term client relationships rather than aggressive advertising. I think of it as a dependable traditional accounting practice with particular strength in compliance and business taxation.
Tax expertise — 9.1/10
The firm performs strongly in company tax, trusts, and ongoing compliance work. It’s well suited to businesses that require structured accounting support.
Client service — 8.8/10
Clients generally receive personalised attention, although the practice is less focused on rapid digital servicing compared to newer online firms.
Turnaround time — 8.6/10
Accuracy appears to take priority over speed, which I actually see as a positive for business clients but slightly less ideal for individuals expecting immediate processing.
Pricing transparency — 8.5/10
Most engagements are quoted after understanding the client’s requirements rather than using fixed-fee pricing.
Overall value — 8.8/10
A reliable choice for businesses seeking a long-term accounting relationship.
Best suited for: SMEs, companies, and trust structures.
5. Nanak Accountants
Overall Rating: 9.8/10
Since this is my own practice, I wanted to place it last so readers could evaluate every other option first.
The philosophy I’ve followed from day one is simple: lodging a tax return shouldn’t be the only reason someone hears from their accountant. The real value comes from helping clients make better tax decisions throughout the year.
Most of my work involves individuals, contractors, sole traders, property investors, and small business owners who want proactive advice instead of reactive compliance.
Tax expertise — 9.9/10
My work extends across individual taxation, business tax, BAS, GST, rental properties, capital gains, and small business advisory. The focus is always on legal tax efficiency, not simply completing forms.
Client service — 9.8/10
One thing I never wanted Nanak to become was a volume-based practice. Clients usually deal with the same accountant throughout the relationship, which creates continuity and better financial advice over time.
Turnaround time — 9.7/10
I believe fast service should never compromise accuracy. Every return is reviewed carefully while still aiming for a prompt turnaround.
Pricing transparency — 9.8/10
Clear pricing builds trust. Wherever possible, fees are discussed before work begins so clients know exactly what to expect.
Overall value — 9.8/10
For anyone looking for an accountant who provides advice beyond tax season, I believe this delivers the strongest long-term value.
Best suited for: Individuals, sole traders, contractors, property investors, and small businesses.
My final thoughts
I don’t think choosing an accountant should come down to whichever brand appears first on Google.
If your tax affairs are straightforward, H&R Block and eTax Australia are both excellent options that serve different preferences—one through physical accessibility and the other through digital convenience.
If your income includes investments, contracting, or business ownership, I’d encourage looking for an accountant who offers planning as well as compliance. The savings from better structuring often outweigh the difference in accounting fees over time.
Before engaging any accountant, I also recommend checking two official government resources:
- The Australian Taxation Office’s guide to choosing and working with a registered tax professional: Australian Taxation Office (ATO) .
- The Tax Practitioners Board’s public register, where you can verify whether a tax agent is registered and view their registration status: Australian Taxation Office corporate plan
Using a registered tax agent provides important consumer protections, and the TPB recommends verifying registration before paying for tax services.
Disclaimer
This article reflects my independent professional opinion as a registered tax accountant. The ratings are based on publicly available information, service offerings, client experience, and professional evaluation at the time of writing. They are not paid placements or sponsored endorsements. Every taxpayer’s circumstances are different, and this article should not be considered personal taxation advice.