Why people are comparing ITP with other accountants
ITP Accounting Professionals has been helping Australians with tax returns for more than 50 years and operates over 240 offices across the country. It’s one of the largest tax accounting networks in Australia and remains a popular choice for employees, contractors, and small businesses looking for accessible tax services.
That said, I’ve noticed more clients comparing ITP with boutique accounting firms rather than simply choosing the biggest brand. The reason is simple: today’s taxpayers often want more than someone who lodges a return. They want advice on rental properties, business structures, GST, capital gains, and long-term tax planning.
This review isn’t about finding faults with ITP. It’s about helping you understand where each firm performs well, and which one is likely to suit your circumstances.
How I rated these firms
I used the same five parameters across every accountant:
- Tax expertise
- Client service
- Turnaround time
- Pricing transparency
- Overall value
These ratings reflect my professional opinion based on publicly available information, service offerings, client feedback, and industry reputation. They are not sponsored rankings.
Read our detailed ITP Accounting Professionals Review.
1. H&R Block
Overall Rating: 9.4/10
If your priority is a reliable individual tax return, H&R Block is one of the strongest alternatives to ITP. Both firms operate large branch networks, but I find H&R Block slightly more consistent in its customer experience across locations.
Tax expertise — 9.5/10
H&R Block has extensive experience with PAYG employees, work-related deductions, rental property income, and standard individual tax returns. It’s particularly well suited to people whose finances aren’t overly complex.
Client service — 9.2/10
The booking process is straightforward and appointments are generally well managed. As with any national network, the experience can vary slightly between offices.
Turnaround time — 9.3/10
Most individual returns are completed efficiently, especially when clients provide complete documentation upfront.
Pricing transparency — 9.4/10
Fees are usually communicated before engagement, making it easier for clients to understand the expected cost.
Overall value — 9.4/10
For straightforward tax returns, H&R Block delivers dependable value and broad accessibility.
Best suited for: Employees, families, and first-time taxpayers.
2. eTax Australia
Overall Rating: 9.2/10
Where ITP focuses on both physical branches and online services, eTax leans heavily into the digital experience. If you rarely visit an accountant’s office, it’s a compelling alternative.
Tax expertise — 9.2/10
The platform performs well across individual tax returns, contractors, and common deduction scenarios. More complex business advice generally requires a more personalised accounting relationship.
Client service — 9.1/10
Communication happens almost entirely online, and that’s exactly why many clients choose it. The process is efficient without feeling overly complicated.
Turnaround time — 9.4/10
Digital document uploads make the entire workflow fast, particularly during tax season.
Pricing transparency — 9.3/10
Pricing is clearly explained before lodging, which gives clients confidence before proceeding.
Overall value — 9.2/10
For anyone who values convenience above everything else, eTax is one of the better online accounting services available.
Best suited for: Professionals who prefer a fully online experience.
3. Kelly+Partners
Overall Rating: 9.0/10
Kelly+Partners isn’t really competing with ITP on volume—it competes on advisory. I generally recommend it to business owners rather than employees because its strength lies beyond tax returns.
Tax expertise — 9.3/10
The firm has strong capability across business taxation, company structures, and financial strategy. That’s where it genuinely stands out.
Client service — 8.9/10
The experience is consultative and detailed. It isn’t designed to be the quickest appointment; it’s designed to provide broader financial guidance.
Turnaround time — 8.8/10
Business advisory naturally involves more planning, so turnaround is slightly longer than high-volume tax preparation firms.
Pricing transparency — 8.7/10
Most engagements are customised, so fees depend on the scope of work rather than fixed pricing.
Overall value — 9.0/10
If you’re building a business rather than simply lodging a return, the advisory element adds meaningful value.
Best suited for: Company directors and growing businesses.
4. Wilson Pateras
Overall Rating: 8.8/10
Wilson Pateras has built its reputation through long-term client relationships rather than aggressive marketing. It’s a dependable Melbourne accounting practice that performs particularly well in business compliance.
Tax expertise — 9.1/10
The firm has solid experience with companies, trusts, and ongoing compliance obligations. It’s well suited to incorporated businesses.
Client service — 8.8/10
Clients typically receive personalised support, although the practice is less digitally focused than newer accounting firms.
Turnaround time — 8.6/10
The emphasis appears to be accuracy over speed, which many business owners actually prefer.
Pricing transparency — 8.5/10
Most fees are quoted after understanding the client’s circumstances, making pricing less predictable than fixed-fee models.
Overall value — 8.8/10
A reliable option for businesses looking for stability and ongoing accounting support.
Best suited for: SMEs, companies, and trust structures.
5. Nanak Accountants
Overall Rating: 9.8/10
I’ve intentionally placed Nanak at the end of this article so readers can evaluate every other option before reading about my own practice.
The biggest difference in my approach is that I don’t see tax returns as a once-a-year service. Most meaningful tax savings happen before 30 June through better planning, better record keeping, and better business decisions.
That philosophy has naturally attracted individuals, contractors, property investors, and small business owners who want an accountant they can speak with throughout the year.
Tax expertise — 9.9/10
My work covers individual taxation, BAS, GST, capital gains, rental properties, sole traders, and small business tax planning. The objective is always legal tax efficiency rather than simply meeting compliance requirements.
Client service — 9.8/10
I believe clients should know who their accountant is. Rather than being passed between different consultants, most clients work with the same accountant year after year.
Turnaround time — 9.7/10
Fast service matters, but accuracy matters more. Every return is reviewed carefully while still aiming for a prompt completion.
Pricing transparency — 9.8/10
Fees are discussed before work begins wherever possible, so clients know exactly what they’re paying for.
Overall value — 9.8/10
For clients looking for proactive tax advice rather than reactive compliance, I believe this offers the strongest long-term value.
Best suited for: Individuals, sole traders, contractors, property investors, and small businesses.
What about ITP itself?
Since this article is about alternatives, it’s only fair to acknowledge where ITP performs well.
ITP has earned its reputation by making tax services accessible across Australia. Its large branch network, experienced tax agents, and broad service offering make it a genuine option for many taxpayers. Public reviews also show a consistent theme: many clients praise knowledgeable local accountants and efficient service, while negative reviews tend to relate to inconsistent experiences between different offices rather than the brand as a whole.
That’s fairly typical of franchise-style accounting networks—your experience often depends on the individual accountant you work with.
My final thoughts
If I were choosing purely for an employee with a straightforward tax return, H&R Block and ITP would both sit comfortably on the shortlist.
If the priority is digital convenience, eTax is hard to overlook.
For business owners and clients whose finances have become more complex, I’d lean towards firms that provide ongoing advisory rather than annual compliance alone. The accountant you choose should ideally help you make better financial decisions throughout the year—not just submit a return to the ATO.
Before engaging any accountant, I’d also recommend verifying that they’re a registered tax agent through the Australian Taxation Office and the Tax Practitioners Board. The TPB’s public register allows you to confirm an accountant’s registration status and professional credentials.
For official guidance on registered tax agents and your obligations as a taxpayer, refer to the Australian Taxation Office.
Disclaimer
This article reflects my independent professional opinion as a registered tax accountant. The ratings are based on publicly available information, service offerings, client experience, and professional evaluation at the time of writing. They are not paid placements or sponsored endorsements. Every taxpayer’s circumstances are different, so this article should not be considered personalised taxation advice.