As an accounting professional and the founder of Nanak Accountants, I don’t judge an accounting firm simply by how many services it offers or how high its online rating appears. I look at what matters to clients in practice: technical knowledge, service range, communication, reliability and whether the overall service provides genuine value.
For this review, I assessed ITP Accounting Professionals using publicly available information about its accounting and tax services, independent customer reviews and industry recognition. I have also considered both positive and negative feedback because I believe an honest accounting review should present the complete picture.
ITP is a long-established Australian tax and accounting brand. Its official website says the business has been operating for more than 50 years and processes more than 200,000 returns annually. Its services extend beyond individual tax returns to bookkeeping, sole trader, partnership, trust and company tax returns, SMSF, financial planning and lending services.
Based on my assessment across five key areas, I give ITP Accounting Professionals an overall score of 4.3/5.
The 5 Factors I Use to Judge ITP
I assessed ITP against the following five factors:
- Tax and accounting expertise
- Range of services
- Communication and client service
- Reputation and consistency
- Value for money and convenience
These are the areas I consider most important when deciding whether an accounting firm is worth recommending.
1. Tax & Accounting Expertise — 4.6/5
The first thing I look at is technical capability.
An accountant’s role should go beyond simply entering figures and lodging a tax return. I want to see whether a firm has the experience and systems to deal with different taxpayer circumstances, business structures and compliance requirements.
ITP has considerable scale and longevity. According to its website, the organisation has been operating for more than 50 years and completes more than 200,000 tax returns each year. It also provides services for individuals, sole traders, partnerships, trusts and companies.
That range tells me that ITP has built significant experience dealing with different types of tax situations.
I also found positive customer feedback supporting this. For example, an ITP Sydney CBD review describes the accountant as thorough, communicative and capable of handling more complicated calculations involving investments and different income sources.
There are, however, negative reviews where customers questioned the quality of advice they received from particular offices. Because ITP operates through a network of offices, I would be careful about assuming that the experience at one branch automatically represents every ITP office.
From an expert perspective, I see the overall technical infrastructure and experience as a major strength, but the individual accountant still matters.
My rating: 4.6/5
2. Range of Accounting & Financial Services — 4.7/5
The second factor I consider is how much of a client’s financial journey the firm can support.
ITP performs well here.
Its current service offering includes in-office and online tax returns, bookkeeping, sole trader tax returns, partnership tax returns, trust tax returns, company tax returns, SMSF services, financial planning and home and car loans.
I particularly like this breadth from a business owner’s perspective.
A client may initially approach an accountant for an individual tax return and later need help with a business, company structure, bookkeeping or other financial matters. Having access to multiple services can make that transition easier.
ITP also provides an online tax-return option, which may suit people who prefer digital processes rather than visiting an office.
However, I would distinguish between having a service available and having specialist expertise for every complex situation. For matters such as complicated business structures, international tax or highly specialised transactions, I would still recommend asking exactly which professional will handle the work and what their relevant experience is.
My rating: 4.7/5
3. Communication & Client Service — 4.3/5
This is an area where I look beyond the company’s marketing.
For me, an accountant can have excellent technical knowledge, but if clients struggle to communicate with them or don’t receive updates on important matters, the overall service suffers.
There is positive evidence here.
Recent Google reviews collected through Trustindex for ITP’s Campbelltown network include customers describing the service as professional, friendly, knowledgeable and fast. One recent customer specifically praised the ability of the accountant to explain financial matters clearly.
There are also strong individual-office reviews. For example, a Kurri Kurri ITP listing shows 4.8/5 from six Google reviews, with customers mentioning professional service, helpfulness and knowledgeable staff.
But I also found criticism that I think prospective clients should know about.
Trustpilot currently shows ITP at 3.2/5 from seven reviews, with several recent reviews raising concerns about delays, communication and service quality. One reviewer reported waiting more than three months for a tax return, while others described problems with appointments and follow-up.
Because ITP operates across many offices, I would not automatically apply these complaints to every branch. Still, they are relevant when assessing the overall customer-service experience.
My rating: 4.3/5
4. Client Reputation & Consistency — 4.1/5
This is probably the most complicated category in my assessment.
ITP clearly has a substantial customer base and strong recognition. Canstar Blue’s 2025 tax-agent research named Income Tax Professionals (ITP) as its top pick, with five-star results across categories including customer service, value for money, quality of advice, turnaround time, ease of use, website and app experience, and overall satisfaction.
That is a significant positive indicator because the recognition comes from consumer research rather than ITP’s own marketing.
At the same time, online reviews are noticeably inconsistent between individual offices and platforms.
For example, the Campbelltown review profile currently shows 4.6/5 from 1,526 Google reviews, with the majority being five-star reviews.
On the other hand, Trustpilot currently shows 3.2/5 from seven reviews, with several one-star experiences.
I don’t think either number should be viewed in isolation.
The important point I take from this is that ITP is a large network, and the quality of the client experience can depend heavily on the individual office and professional handling the account.
That is something I would consider before making a decision.
My rating: 4.1/5
5. Value for Money & Convenience — 4.2/5
The final factor I assess is value.
I don’t define value as simply finding the cheapest tax accountant. I look at what the client receives for the fee, how convenient the process is and whether the service saves the client time while providing appropriate professional advice.
ITP offers both traditional in-office appointments and online tax-return services. Its website states that online returns can be completed in minutes and checked by its experts.
The organisation’s scale also gives it an advantage in terms of accessibility, with a large network of offices across Australia.
Canstar Blue’s 2025 research is another positive indicator here, with ITP receiving five-star results for value for money as well as several other customer-experience categories.
However, I found some customers on Trustpilot who questioned pricing and whether the service received matched what they expected to pay. One reviewer specifically raised concerns about being charged more than an advertised price for a basic return.
For that reason, I would recommend confirming the exact fee and what is included before proceeding.
My rating: 4.2/5
My ITP Accounting Professionals Rating
| Factor | My Rating |
| Tax & Accounting Expertise | 4.6/5 |
| Range of Services | 4.7/5 |
| Communication & Client Service | 4.3/5 |
| Client Reputation & Consistency | 4.1/5 |
| Value for Money & Convenience | 4.2/5 |
| Overall Rating | 4.3/5 |
My Final Verdict on ITP Accounting Professionals
After looking at ITP across these five areas, I give ITP Accounting Professionals an overall rating of 4.3/5.
The biggest strengths I see are its long operating history, broad range of tax and accounting services, large Australian network and strong industry recognition. I also found many positive customer experiences describing ITP professionals as knowledgeable, friendly, professional and helpful.
The main area where I would exercise caution is consistency between offices.
ITP is a large network, and the public reviews show that customer experiences can differ considerably. Some offices receive very strong feedback, while reviews on broader platforms raise concerns about delays, communication, pricing and service quality.
As an accounting professional, I don’t see that as a reason to dismiss ITP altogether. Instead, I would recommend evaluating the specific ITP office and accountant you intend to use.
Before engaging them, I would ask:
- Who will personally handle my tax or accounting work?
- What experience do they have with my situation?
- What services are included in the quoted fee?
- Are there additional charges for amendments or follow-up work?
- How long should I expect the return or accounts to take?
- How will I communicate with the accountant if I have questions?
I would also check the tax practitioner’s registration and understand my own responsibilities as a client.
The Australian Taxation Office (ATO) explains that registered tax agents must meet qualification and experience requirements and comply with the Tax Agent Services Act and Code of Professional Conduct. The ATO also recommends discussing the services and expectations with your agent before engaging them.
For businesses, the ATO also requires certain entities with an ABN to nominate their registered agent when engaging a new agent or changing the authorisations given to an existing agent.
My final rating: 4.3/5
Where I Took the Reviews From
I used several sources rather than relying solely on ITP’s own website.
ITP Accounting Professionals — Official Website
I used ITP’s official website to assess its current service offering, business history, online tax-return process and specialist accounting services. ITP states that it has been operating for more than 50 years and processes more than 200,000 returns annually.
Canstar Blue
Canstar Blue’s 2025 tax-agent research named Income Tax Professionals (ITP) as its top-rated tax-agent brand, with five-star ratings across customer service, value for money, quality of advice, turnaround time, ease of use, website/app experience and overall satisfaction.
Trustindex / Google Reviews
I reviewed ITP’s publicly surfaced Google reviews, including the Campbelltown profile showing 4.6/5 from 1,526 reviews. The reviews include both positive and negative customer experiences, which I considered when assessing consistency.
Trustpilot
Trustpilot currently lists ITP at 3.2/5 from seven reviews. I considered the recent complaints regarding delays, communication and pricing as part of the balanced assessment. Because the sample is small, I would not treat this score as representative of every ITP office.
ProductReview
ProductReview also contains individual customer experiences relating to ITP tax returns, including positive comments about helpfulness, professional service and knowledge, as well as mixed customer feedback.
Australian Taxation Office
I used the ATO as the authoritative source for information concerning registered tax agents, client responsibilities and agent nomination requirements.
Review Methodology
This is an independent expert assessment written from my perspective as an accounting professional.
The 4.6, 4.7, 4.3, 4.1 and 4.2 ratings are my own editorial scores based on the five criteria explained above. They are not ITP’s ratings, nor are they an average of the customer reviews found online.
Online ratings and review counts can change over time. I have therefore treated them as supporting evidence rather than as the sole basis for my conclusion.